Okay! That is a lot! Also, something about Tally on the verge of tears makes Magnus want to reach out and take care of her, even though he still doesn't really like her, which is weird. Okay, time to focus on her eyebrow again! Aiming for a thoroughly non-judgemental and neutral tone, he says, "Okay, so can you break that down for me a little further? How did you steal him from Shay? How did you 'accidentally' get his town destroyed?"